Skip to main content
Crypto News Today
Latest podcast

From the archive · Football & regulation

Why Arsenal’s fan-token ads fell foul of the UK advertising regulator

A vote on the music after a win sounded like a simple supporters’ poll. The route from an Arsenal post to a tradeable token was what drew the regulator’s attention.

ASA ruling Reviewed
Editorial illustration of a brass football token resting on a red and white scarf in a stadium.
Editorial illustration · Crypto News Today

The invitation supporters saw

In July 2021, Socios announced a partnership with Arsenal to launch the AFC Fan Token. It pitched polls and club experiences as reasons to take part. A subsequent Arsenal Facebook post asked supporters to help choose the song played after a win. An Arsenal webpage described how the token worked.

Buying a token was several steps removed from casting a vote. The paid version involved buying Chiliz, exchanging it for AFC tokens and holding an asset whose market value could change. Eligible Arsenal members could instead claim a free, non-transferable token. A reader seeing the Facebook post had to understand which of those journeys it was inviting them to take.

Why the warning’s position mattered

Arsenal told the Advertising Standards Authority that the programme was designed to engage fans. Its webpage carried a warning about possible losses, and a single token was enough to take part in a poll. The ASA considered how the promotion would read to a supporter encountering it in isolation. The Facebook post omitted important information and the webpage placed its warning where a reader could engage further before seeing it.

The ruling published on 10 August 2022 upheld the complaints. The ASA instructed the club to stop running those ads in that form. The decision concerned how the two promotions presented the product. It left the football club free to run a supporters’ poll.

The date matters when reading the decision

The UK framework subsequently changed. From 8 October 2023, the UK financial promotions regime applied to marketing qualifying cryptoassets to UK consumers. An old advertising ruling tells you what the ASA decided about these particular posts. Someone assessing a new campaign needs the rules in force for that promotion and product.

For a supporter offered a similar benefit, three practical questions follow. What does the free route give you? What changes if you pay? Can you sell what you bought, and at what price? In this case the difference between those answers was central to the story.